Just a girl obsessed with books and movies sharing her thoughts.

The Song of Achilles : book review

Written in


I fell in love with Circe by Madeline Miller and I had to read the book that made her debut, The Song of Achilles. Picture Greece in the age of heroes, the narrator is Patroclus son of Menoetius, that makes him a prince but a quite awkward prince in his manner. After a terrible incident, Patroclus is being exiled to Peleus kingdom and that’s where he rubs shoulders with the magnifient Achilles. Greatly moving and original, this retelling of The Trojan War is a brilliant feast of imagination, history and mythology, filled with the angers of the Gods and the human loves and hearts. It sparks a conversation about sexuality, contrasting with duty and loyalty towards the House of the Greek Empires.

The character development was always the main strength of Madeleine Miller, Patroclus comes from the most unusual background among the princes of Greece, he starts with an odd and awkward character, staying in his lane and we get to witness his evolution to assert his character and values, not shying away from figures of authorities.

The only complain I would have is that once the buildup of the relationship was over and once the characters join the Greek’s side in Trojan War, it got boring and dull. Not because the Trojan War is not interesting, but because I feel like I have heard of this war a thousand times that I actually was actively searching for elements that would surprise me, threw me off guard or made me learn something new. But all I got was the exact retelling of the Trojan War, no greater contributions.

However, this is a beautiful tale of love, worship and war, where mortals and Gods come together and Madeline Miller did a wonderful job with her prose and the wonderful characters.

Rating: 3.8/5

Have you read this book? Did you like it ? Share your thoughts in the comments below! 🙂



8 responses to “The Song of Achilles : book review”

  1. S.D. McKinley Avatar
    S.D. McKinley

    Did you find that the story was more raw and had more energy as a debut than Circe? Or did the author ‘ramp’ things up so-to-speak for Circe?


  2. Katrina Avatar

    I thought that The Song of Achilles was certainly more raw and emotional than Circe, in Circe I felt held back a step from the characters whilst in Achilles they felt more whole and easier to connect to.


  3. Meggy | Chocolate'n'Waffles Avatar

    So happy I am not the only one who thinks that it gets dull at some point!!! I enjoyed it but gosh that part was loooooong! FAB REVIEW! xxx


  4. todd Avatar

    Like you, after reading and loving Circe, I also picked up The Song of Achilles. But I’ve yet to read it, so it’s still something I’m looking forward to. Glad to hear you enjoyed most of it.


  5. Lois Avatar

    The Song of Achilles is possibly one of my favourite books I’ve read this year. I love Patroclus as the narrator because his voice humanised Achilles in a way no one else could. We see Achilles brilliance, arrogance, and power, but we also got to see the boy underneath, the one that only Patroclus was privy to. It made their romance all the more endearing, making the events of the Trojan war strike a more emotional chord. I still need to get my hands on Circe. Love the review. 😀

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Books Teacup and Reviews Avatar

    I want to read this one and I will read it before Circe that I’m sure, from what I heard, is even better than this one. Amazing review!


  7. Baby It’s Cold Outside Book Tag (Original❄️) – Reading On A Star Avatar

    […] @ A Little Haze // Rendz @ Reading with Rendz // Lori @ The Reading Fairy // Orangutan Librarian // Lashaan @ Bookidote // Luna @ Bookish Luna // Emme @ A Literary Latte // Noura @ The Perks of Being Noura // Laura @ […]


  8.  Avatar

    The book a The Song of Achilles was amazing, it always left me in tears. It was one of these books which tears me apart and gave me the motivation and dedication into Greek Mythology once more. I can honestly say likewise for Circe but The Song of Achilles made me weep and not want to read anything anymore, it sinks in deeply and has been the 1st book out of hundreds I have enjoyed greatly for the last 3 years. I recommend both The Song of Achilles and Circe to anyone interested in Greek Mythology!!!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: